Open Methodological Questions
Open Methodological Questions
This page tracks methodological questions the SSWG has raised but not yet resolved. It is a living tracker, not a one-time snapshot — it should be updated as each item is resolved, and it is expected to shrink over time, not grow. Per this guidance's own constraints, none of these questions is resolved on any other page: where a page touches one of these topics, it presents the live debate and links back here rather than picking an answer.
| # | Question | Status | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Average vs. marginal water intensity — which approach(es) should implementers use for EWIF? | Open — to be addressed in a revised EWIF brief | Ryan Sholin |
| 2 | Freshwater vs. saltwater scope — should saltwater withdrawal be included in this version of the specification? | Open — requires research support; a structured menu of options has been proposed | Ryan Sholin |
| 3 | Annual vs. monthly EWIF update cycle — what does backtesting the difference reveal? | Open — backtesting committed to, not yet complete | Ryan Sholin |
| 4 | ISO 14046:2014 as normative reference — is it compatible with SWI's consumption/withdrawal definitions? | Open — awaiting review | Sean McIlroy / Yi Ding |
| 5 | Non-potable vs. potable freshwater distinction — should the specification distinguish between these? | Flagged but not resolved | Group |
| 6 | Reservoir hydro apportionment — what is the agreed methodology for allocating reservoir evaporation across industries? | Partially addressed; needs resolution | Ryan Sholin / Yi Ding |
Why these live here, and not in the specification
The specification does not take a position on any of the six questions above, and this guidance does not either — presenting an unresolved question as settled, even implicitly, would misrepresent where the SSWG actually stands. Each linked page above explains the question in context and flags it as open at the point where a reader would otherwise expect a definitive answer.
Updating this page
When the SSWG resolves one of these questions, update its Status column here, and update the corresponding page(s) to reflect the resolved position rather than presenting it as still open. Do not remove a resolved row silently — note the resolution and the date, so the history of how the methodology settled remains visible.
Please submit any comments you have here.